Toby Aromolaran was a 24-year-old Semi-Professional Footballer from Essex when he finished in fourth place on the first season of Love Island: All Stars. He originally appeared on Season 7 where he was runner-up with Chloe Burrows and also appeared on Love Island Games. Toby returned for All Stars on Day 1 and was coupled up with Georgia Steel by the public. They finished in fourth place with 10% of the vote.