Johnny Middlebrooks

Johnny Middlebrooks made a dramatic entrance to Love Island USA Season 2 when he arrived after the first coupling and immediately stole Cely from Tre on Day 2. The Chesapeake, Virginia native became one of the most talked-about contestants of the season, particularly due to his controversial behavior during Casa Amor that tested his relationship with Cely. Despite the drama, Johnny and Cely finished as runners-up, though their relationship faced scrutiny from viewers. His Love Island story continued with appearances on Love Island Games Seasons 1 and 2, cementing his status as a franchise regular.