Kaitlynn Anderson

Kaitlynn Anderson entered the Love Island USA Season 2 villa on Day 1 as an original islander from Lapeer, Michigan, hoping to find love from the start of the season. She initially coupled with Carrington, but when Johnny arrived and needed to steal a girl, the resulting shuffle left Kaitlynn vulnerable. She became the first contestant dumped from Season 2 on Day 5 after failing to secure a coupling, setting an early example of how quickly fortunes can change in the villa. Her brief stay was a reminder that even original islanders aren't guaranteed safety.