Mark "Papa Bear" Caruso

Mark Papa Bear Caruso finished seventeenth on Survivor: South Pacific as the second person voted out. As a retired NYPD detective from New York, he was the oldest person in the game that season at 48 years old. He struggled to fit in with the younger Savaii tribe and was targeted early for being on the outs. Papa Bear attempted to bluff having a Hidden Immunity Idol but was voted out regardless.