Dolly Neely

Dolly Neely was a 25-year-old Sheep Farmer from Lake Latonka, Pennsylvania when she competed on Survivor: Vanuatu as the youngest woman of the season. Growing up on her family's farm and attending Westminster College, Dolly was placed on the all-female Yasur tribe and quickly found herself in the swing vote position between the younger women's alliance and the older women's alliance. Her attempts to play both sides and keep her options open backfired spectacularly when Eliza Orlins, fearing Dolly would flip on her, betrayed her to the older women. Dolly was blindsided on Day 6, becoming the first woman eliminated and a cautionary tale about the dangers of being perceived as wishy-washy.